Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes

This entry was posted in Muffins & Cupcakes and tagged , on by .

Impossible Perfect Fall treat! De-lic-ious Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes.
Impossible-Pumpkin-Pie-Cupcakes

It’s crazy how you blink and summer is over…I relax just a bit when mornings become misty and leaves begin to drop.  It’s bitter sweat… no I didn’t misspell that… it is sweat! For me, Fall is a magical time of year, it means more baking, warm fires, endless opportunities for seasonal photos and that sweet spot before the holiday chaos.

Today, Fall is in the air….can you smell pumpkin spice everything yet?
A perfect time to introduce fall blockbuster….just like a apple pie,  just like a Guardians of the Galaxy,  just like being able to wear a pair of laid-back Levi’s jeans….Impossible pumpkin pie cupcakes.
I know you’re probably surprised to see that picture of cupcakes up there because, as I’ve mentioned before, I usually do not like cupcakes. Personally, I think they’re too typical – Yet, I must say that this recipe is a huge departure from a typical cupcake. It’s one of my most requested recipes each year. I mean, just LOOK at these cupcakes! They’re beautiful, and I promise, they’re very tasty.

Impossible-Pumpkin-Pie-Cupcakes

They taste just like pumpkin pie filling, but are sturdy enough to eat with your hands. You’ll love these because they’re not overly sweet, and they’re pumpkin-y without being overpowering, plus the batter is crazy easy to make too.
If you love pumpkin pie and are tired of waiting until Thanksgiving these cupcakes are the perfect way to get your fix, but they’re also great to pack up and give as a Thanksgiving take-home gifts.

Note : This post contains recipe and preparation method on second page


Need I say more? Turn on the page 2 and let’s prepare some delicious Pumpkin pie cupcakes….

113 thoughts on “Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes

  1. Pingback: Pumpkin Pie Recipe Variations - Clever Pink Pirate » Clever Pink Pirate

  2. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes | Food- Mafia

    1. Janis

      Are you certain that you didn’t leave out the baking powder? Other than than, they could have been slightly undercooked & would fall when they cooled. They look amazing; I can’t wait to go get the ingredients & try them~~ Here’s hoping they’re as good as they look!

      Reply
    2. Patricia

      I saw this recipe on what I believe was the original site. In her post, she said that the cupcakes WILL fall in the middle once taken out of the oven, the way a pumpkin pie does.

      I am looking forward to trying these soon! :)

      Reply
    3. Amanda

      I bake for a living. You either left out the baking powder, under baked them, or over beat them. Only ever mix in flour till incorporated, not a minute longer.

      Reply
    4. Judie

      Just made these pumpkin cupcakes and they are delicious. Only problem is they fell in the middle and stuck to the cupcake paper.

      Reply
  3. Cara

    Would I be able to make a gluten free one? What would you suggest? Curious as my dad is allergic to everything under the sun it seems.

    Reply
    1. Dan Post author

      Cara,
      I really wouldn’t know that for sure, but I think that you could use gluten free flour, (maybe Garbanzo bean flour) in the same amount like the all-purpose flour, instead of sugar a few packets of Stevia and some agave……
      Let me know how that turned out.

      Reply
    2. fragilemuse

      I’m attempting gluten free ones right now, using an all purpose gluten free flour from Bulk Barn! I’ll let you know how it goes. :)

      Reply
      1. Kat

        Curious how they turned out. I’m dairy and gluten free and wondering if these are going to take more experimenting than I’m willing to do to get right.

        Reply
    3. Donna

      Use Cup 4 Cup flour. It’s gluten free and is literally cup for cup to all purpose flour. It’s a superior substitute. You can order it online.

      Reply
      1. Brenda

        I dont recommend using coconut flour as a straight sub. It is an egg hog and has distinctive flavor and texture.

        Reply
    4. christine wood

      Try replacing the flour with Namaste’s All Purpose Flour Blend. It is GF., Diary Free, Egg Free, Nut Free. I am GF and use it to replace flour in some recipes. Same ratio.

      Good Luck….I have been pleasantly surprised that the baked items come out amazing! Whole Foods carries it. You can also find them online.

      Reply
    5. David Lee

      Humans have been eating gluten for at least the last 50,000 years, Cara and we’ve been doing OK. Why you people fall for these FAD diets is a mystery to me.

      Reply
      1. Kay

        Some of us have a serious condition called celiac disease. This disease is very debilitating if you ingest gluten. The patient can have severe gastric distress, fatigue for 5 days after ingestion and bowel cancer if they keep eating gluten.

        There are many that are gluten sensitive too!!

        I use Better Batter all purpose gluten free flower. We use this 1:1 with all baking. We have tried all the blends, and Better Batter is the best. We buy online in bulk!

        Reply
      2. Maria

        David, I only wish it were a fad diet. If you dont have celiac disease, you cannot imagine the pain experienced when you even accidently eat a bite of food containing gluten. I have watched my sister suffer from this for years before she was diagnosed. when she started eating gluten free and really reading labels, the results were immediate. She can now enjoy going out to eat again because she now knows what she needs to avoid. these gluten free recipes are a godsend for her and for me too. i can make her cake for her birthday and if shes coming to my house for dinner, i can accommodate her without a problem. I’m happy to have found a new place to find recipes. I can’t wait to try it|

        Reply
      3. Pam

        OMG. Are you serious? Have you ever heard of celiac disease? Not a fad diet….an absolutely necessity to not eat gluten if you are diagnosed with celiac disease! Don’t be so ignorant.

        Reply
      4. Mrs C

        David Lee, food over the past 30 years have made genetic changes that truly effect us. I never dreamt I was allergic to gluten until last year. Allergies are no fun. Do a little reading about current wheat vs the wheat from even 40 years ago. It’s NOT the same. Genetic alterations are good for big food corporations and huge farmers but not good for for people eating it. Please read up before you jump to conclusions that are inaccurate.

        Reply
    6. Vickie Rodgers

      I make all of the impossible pies recipes from the Bisquick site using gf bisquick. I also use Almond milk or non dairy coffee creamer and Earth Balance Vegan butter to make them gluten and lactose free. Amazing!!!!!!

      Reply
    1. Dan Post author

      I’m sorry Jade, I didn’t try with this cupcakes that so I can’t tell, but in most cases before, following method do the trick.
      Line the bottom of an airtight container with paper towels, line up your freshly baked cupcakes without whipped cream frosting,
      then top with another layer of paper towels before sealing with the lid. The paper towels will absorb the extra moisture,
      and cupcakes should retain most of their texture and flavor for up to couple of days.
      Hope these will be helpful.

      Reply
  4. Becky

    I made these cupcakes and although they wetr shper easy to make and taste delicious I couldn’t peel off the cupcake liners. Did I do something wrong?

    Reply
    1. JEnn

      Even though this recipe says to use paper liners, you should not use paper liners. According to a different site with the same recipe:
      “Line 12 muffin tins with silicone liners, foil liners sprayed with cooking spray, or just spray the muffin tin with cooking spray. Either of these three methods will make it easy to take the cupcake out after it’s cooked. Paper liners make it difficult to remove the cupcake.”
      I hope this helps.

      Reply
      1. Kim

        I made them using the gold foil-looking liners from the baking section and the pies came out really well. (Especially after they have been in the refrigerator). Delicious pie-cupcakes!

        Reply
  5. Pingback: Funky Finds: All things Pumpkin - ProfessionGal

  6. Denna palmer

    i have a question please, can you substitute can pumpkin pie filling for the pumpkin puree, i can not wait to make these but i want to be sure before i do. great recipe by the way! love it. thank you.

    Reply
    1. Dan Post author

      Hi Denna,
      Thank you for kind words.
      I made it with homemade pumpkin puree, because i prefer homemade food (usually cheaper than store-bought, easy to make, and definitely healthier…), but you could use canned pumpkin pie filling as well.
      Hope these will be helpful.

      Reply
    2. Joan

      There’s a big difference between canned pumpkin pie filling and canned pumpkin puree. Never ,NEVER substitute the pie filling for the puree or your recipe won’t work.

      Reply
  7. Christa

    I made these exactly as recipe said and had to bake them 30 minutes and they were still moist in center. When I took them out of the oven they fell in the center

    Reply
  8. Susan

    I made these cupcakes and they didn’t turn out like your picture shows. They fell in the center and we couldn’t get them out of the wrappers.. I didn’t forget the baking powder or baking soda and I checked to see if they were done before taking them out of the oven. I had to cook an extra 10 minutes as they were still liquidy in the center. My temp of my oven is spot-on, so I’m not sure what went wrong… Still, they were yummy.

    Reply
  9. Pingback: Thankful Thursday 10.16.14 | Coffee Chalk

  10. Pingback: On My Radar…workout clothes and all things pumpkin | afitgirlsguide

  11. Maureen

    So delicious! Just made these for a party this evening…with maple whiskey whipped cream. Like others, mine fell like pumpkin pie does…but also they don’t look quite as “custardy” in the middle…Still tasty.

    Reply
  12. Pingback: 10 Pumpkin Recipes You NEED to Try

  13. Tika

    I made these cupcakes today , they were pretty awesome . I kept them in the oven about 10 minutes longer because they werent looking too done in the middle after 20 minutes. , and they turned out perfect , they didn’t fall in the middle like some reviews said. The cupcakes tasted just like a pumpkin pie without the crust.. I think what would have made them even better would be to add some sort of gram cracker crust at the bottom to give it the crunch, like in a pie :)

    Reply
    1. JHughes

      I kept reading the middle was falling with people trying to make these cupcakes, but the picture didn’t show a fallen middle cupcake, so I figured there has to be a solution. I believe you got it right! Thanks for your suggestions! When I try this recipe, I will definitely use your suggestions. I like reading through the comments to see who has tried the recipes and for any pointers to make the recipes better. Thanks again!

      Reply
  14. Ron

    I’m a male and I cook and this receipe is fantastic, I followed the ingredient list and added double everything and a pinch of extra everything except eggs and I sprayed the paper cups with cooking spray and had no problems. Sorry to brag but mine didn’t fall.

    Reply
  15. sallyz

    I made these with home made pumpkin puree, refined coconut oil (don’t use the virgin, too strong for this), coconut sugar, and spelt flour (for no gluten). I filled the cups according to recipe on first batch and decided to add more on second batch to make it higher, due to falling in the middle. I also had to cook them additional 7 minutes first batch and 9 minutes second. I topped them with real whipped cream made from whipping cream and sprinkled toasted pecans mixed with a little cinnamon on top of cream. They did not look as nice as picture but tasted pretty good, not sure if I will make these again though.

    Reply
  16. Pingback: Goals for the Week 11/17-23 - Just Only Home

  17. Pingback: Pumpkin Desserts Delicious Enough for the Thanksgiving Table

  18. Jen

    These look like a great addition to my thanksgiving dessert menu! We are having a few desserts so I thought it might be a good idea to make these as mini-cupcakes instead of full-size. Do you think that would work? And if so, are there any adjustments that I would need to make in terms of cooking time or anything else? I’m not the most experienced baker, so thank you for the advice!

    Reply
  19. joannie kemp

    I made the pumpkin pie cupcakes last month and thet were AMAZING. I LOVED them cold. I will Definitely make them AGAIN!!!!

    Reply
  20. Irethsue

    Thanks for sharing this recipe! I tried it and they turn out amazing! I did some few changes to the recipe based on own my family recipe for pupmkin pie. But thank you very much, I didnt have any issue and we all loved them.

    Reply
  21. Adri

    Hi!… Question…
    Did you let them sit in the oven any amount of time after the 20min… because I am wondering, the heat in the oven continues to cook them even if it is not on and maybe that is why some have to add more cooking time. I am trying these ou and would hate it if they were overcooked. I am also going to try to add the pie crust to the botttom and garnish with candied pecans!!! SO EXCITED!

    Reply
  22. Pingback: » Pumpkin Spice

  23. Melissa King

    We tried these tonight and had to make them twice and both times they sunk in and fell even after leaving them 15 minutes longer the second time around. They tasted really good, but half the cupcake stuck to the paper. Really wanted to make these for Thanksgiving and still would if I could get them right…suggestions??

    Reply
  24. Celena

    I know I lot of people are saying that the middle is falling in on the cupcake and they can’t get the linner off. This reminds me of when I made cheesecake cupcakes. Just let them cool completely, remove linner and the well in cupcake can be filled with cool whip, etc..

    Reply
  25. Heather

    I just made these for my family Thanksgiving, (a little early) and they were a hit! They are so easy to make! I just made them without paper liners, and sprayed the muffin tin with Pam. Easy to hold and taste just like a mini pumpkin pie. Definitely holding on to this recipe for dear life!

    Reply
  26. Tracey

    Loved this recipe. My son couldn’t wait for the 30 minutes in the fridge. He thought they were just okay. When I gave him another after the 30 minutes he LOVED them. So be patient and wait the extra time.

    Mine fell a bit too. But once you add the whip cream people are too busy stuffing them into their faces to notice.

    Reply
  27. Pingback: 7 Recipes to complete your Thanksgiving spread | Colupon

  28. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes - Cakescottage ...

  29. Pingback: #MixxMunchies: Thanksgiving Edition – The Mixx Magazine

  30. Kelsi

    I made these for Thanksgiving instead of our traditional pumpkin pie. Mine also fell in drastically despite following the recipe exactly as written. Also, I had batter left over, even though I used the 1/3 cup for each. Finally, it took much longer than 20 minutes for them to bake. I added an additional 10 minutes if not longer and they were still iffy. Despite all this, they were delicious even if they didn’t look like the picture.

    Reply
  31. E

    Make sure you use pumpkin puree, not pumpkin pie filling. Also if you use homemade pumpkin puree make sure it is well drained. This can affect the falling in issues.

    Reply
  32. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes

  33. Lorraine

    I am in Australia and would love to make these muffins but would like to know what spices I can use to make up the pumpkin pie spice mentioned in the above ingredient list as it is not available here .Can anyone help please?

    Reply
  34. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes | F o o d t o t a s t e

  35. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes | ShareAtopia

  36. Pingback: What I'm Into Volume 11 - A Pop of Pink

  37. Pingback: Pumpkin Pie in a Cupcake — Timeless Treasure Trove

  38. Pingback: Impossible Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes via @Dan | CakesCottage | Find Your Best Stuff Here

  39. Pingback: Homemade Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes Recipes

  40. Natalie

    I made these the other day after reading tons of reviews where people said theirs collapsed a lot after cooling or were mushy in the middle. I made two batches; one using regular all purpose flour and the other using King Arthur’s all purpose gluten free flour. To combat the problem of mushiness or collapsing, I added an extra Tablespoon of flour. The recipe says to fill the cups 1/3 full, which comes out to about one and a half dozen cupcakes. If you only use 12 cups, you will need to increase the baking time. I made 12 from each batch and baked them for 35 minutes. Like a pumpkin pie, they will puff up during baking then fall some as they cool. Neither of mine collapsed in the center and both remained even across the top. I was surprised the gluten free ones settled higher than the ones with regular flour. In a side by side comparison, there was only a very slight difference in texture, but you’d never know it if you had them alone. I actually thought there was more pumpkin pie flavor in the gluten free batch than the other. The centers will not be fluffy like a cupcake, but somewhat creamy like a pie, though firmer. I made these to serve with coffee one morning so I didn’t add any topping. They were the perfect treat to go with it and my friends loved them!

    Reply
  41. Bethany Brillhart

    Hello! I really want to make these for my husbands lunch bucket this fall but every time I refresh the page or such the recipe leaves out the amount of pumpkin puree in its place is an empty blank square. Can anyone help a girl out?

    Reply
  42. Pingback: Pumpkin recipes that will make you wish fall would never end! - The Creek Line House

  43. Pingback: The Best Pumpkin Recipes — Today's Every Mom

  44. Pingback: 6 Pinterest Pumpkin Recipes You Have to Try - BLONDEetc.

  45. Danielle

    There are 2 squares in place of numbers in the recipe. The first is in the ingredient list: how many cups of flour? The second is in step six: how much batter do you fill the cup with? I believe these are both supposed to be the number one, but want to make sure! Thanks :)

    Reply
  46. Lil

    Saw this recipe and it looked and sounded delish and easy. Since I love pumpkin pie but don’t care much for the crust I decided to try it. I used home made butternut squash puree (I usually use that instead of pumpkin because it’s available year round) they just came out of the oven and yes they fell but look good, can’t wait to try them. Next time I’m going to try it with whole wheat flour and using honey instead of sugar. Thanks for sharing!!!

    Reply
    1. Brenda

      Evaporated milk is much thicker. I might try full fat coconut milk in can instead, and possibly add more flour.

      Reply
  47. Pingback: Activities and Food for Fall (Fun for the Whole Family) - Mom Is Forever

  48. Pingback: 50+ non-pie Pumpkin Desserts » Lolly Jane

  49. Pingback: 57 Easy Homemade Pumpkin Pie Ideas For The Holidays - Pie Addict

  50. Pingback: Our Favorite Pumpkin Recipes That Aren't Pumpkin Pie - Mother Rucker’s Sweets

  51. Pingback: Inspired By Marie Calendar’s » Live Fit: This is my journey

  52. Joyce

    I made these last night. I used cupcake size pan and not muffin size. I cooked the full 20 minutes. They looked nice in the oven, but they fell. The flavor is just the k, very sweet fir my taste. To get an actual cupcake size you would have to fill the pan 3/4 full.

    Reply
  53. Jessica Valure

    I can’t have regular flower or sugar so I would substitute the flower with cornmeal flower and sugar with sweet and low wonder if it would taste as good

    Reply
  54. Pingback: 30+ of the BEST Fall Dessert Recipes - Kitchen Fun With My 3 Sons

  55. Pingback: 30+ of the BEST Fall Dessert Recipes | Nifymag.com

  56. Pingback: 10 Fall Cupcake Recipes You Have to Check Out! - Testing for the Best Thing

  57. Rose Marie

    I have made this 3 times now and the first time they came out like the pictures. Second was a gloppy mess and third was heading for the gloppy mess BUT I had forgotten to let them cool and place them in the fridge. You have to let them cool to finish. They are exactly like pumpkin pie they don’t stay fluffy like cake. Please don’t skip the cooling or fridge time.

    Reply
  58. Shyanne

    Mine turned out great but I am not serving them until tomorrow. Should I keep them refrigerated over night or does it matter?

    Reply
  59. Pingback: Creative ideas for this ‘Pumpkin Season’ | niagaraveggies

  60. Brittany

    I got this little nifty tip from:http://www.everythingpies.com/pie-filling-shrinking/
    Hope it helps…!!!

    Keep your pie from falling, cracking, and shrinking.
    1. Remember hot temperatures cook the crust and low temperatures cook the filling. So put the pie in a hot oven and drop the temperature after 10 to 15 minutes.

    2. To slow down the shrinkage or falling of the filling, let the pie cool down in the oven gradually.

    When the pie crust is completely cooked and golden, turn off the oven but leave the pie in.

    Let it sit in the oven for 10 to 15 minutes in an off-oven. Crack open the oven door, and let the pie cool down slowly for 10 to 20 minutes more.

    Now it should be safe to remove the pie.

    Why leave the pie in the oven while it is off?

    What we are doing is allowing the filling to gain strength as it cools down.

    The process of slowly cooling the pie filling allows the starches (thickeners) or custard to build strength and body. This will support the structure of the pie filling as the rising steam in the pie stops its support of the filling.

    If this is done correctly, it will minimize the pie filling falling, cracking and shrinking.

    Some Do Nots to follow

    Do not let the pie filling puff up like a souffle.
    Do not let custard based fillings cook until the center is completely set.
    Remember low heat will cook the center only. High heat will only cook the crust. We need to be in the middle with the hopes that the crust and filling will complete baking at the same time.

    Reply
  61. Pingback: Daily Recipe Find – Sunday Sweets – Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes | Smiles and Trials

  62. Krystal

    There are a few things I would tweak with this recipe. I would most definitely fill the cupcake liner at least 3/4 the way full as suggested in one of the comments above. The first batch I followed the instructions precisely and even with using the baking powder, the cupcakes still fell quite a bit and only turned out to be about an inch in height when filling up the liner with 1/3 cup of batter as instructed. The second batch is in the oven and I am baking them for at least 25-30 minutes because the first batch were undercooked at 20 minutes. The smell is amazing and my husband is very happy I have started baking again for the holiday season. We will see how the second batch turns out!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Rate this recipe: